Chapter 6 — The Decision
Cid finally turned around.
He looked at the house.
At the windows.
For a moment he saw only the porch light trembling in the glass.
The dark street behind him.
The brick looked ordinary.
The curtains looked ordinary.
The basement window was a black rectangle sunk halfway into the foundation.
Then the dark behind the glass changed.
Not movement.
Not exactly.
More like the darkness had decided to keep its shape.
Something was there.
A figure.
Small.
Still.
Too still.
Cid forgot to breathe.
At first it was only an outline.
A young girl standing just behind the basement glass.
She did not move.
She did not blink.
She only stood there.
Watching him.
The porch light slid across the window and caught the fabric she wore.
White.
Soft sleeves.
A hem too wide for running.
He knew that dress.
His friend’s favorite dress.
For one terrible instant the years between Chicago and Nicaragua gave way.
The house next door.
The hallway in his grandmother’s home.
The smell in the walls.
The stopped clock.
The certainty that something in that house had known he was there.
Past and present folded into each other.
The girl behind the glass did not move.
She only watched him.
The porch light flickered.
For an instant her reflection appeared beside her in the window.
Not over her shoulder.
Beside her.
If you encounter this tale on Amazon, note that it's taken without the author's consent. Report it.
As if there were two girls standing in the dark.
Cid’s stomach turned cold.
Then he saw what was wrong.
The reflection was not looking at him.
It was looking past her.
Toward the door behind her.
The light steadied.
The reflection vanished.
The girl remained.
Still watching.
“Cid.”
A hand touched his shoulder.
Cid jerked so hard his teeth clicked.
Dave stood beside him.
“What’s wrong?”
Cid kept his eyes on the basement window.
“I saw something.”
Dave followed his gaze.
“In the window?”
Cid nodded once.
“A girl.”
Dave studied the glass.
Five seconds.
Ten.
Nothing.
No figure.
No white dress.
Only darkness and the faint reflection of the street.
Dave looked back at him.
“Come on,” he said quietly.
The others were already near the cars. Mike secured the camera case. Ruben slipped his notebook into his coat. Tomas closed the file. Pastor Elias stepped off the porch while the grandmother stayed in the doorway behind him.
Then the door shut.
They left Loomis Street just before dark.
The church basement felt almost offensive when they returned.
Fluorescent lights.
Metal chairs.
Old file cabinets.
The smell of stale coffee and paper.
No cold in the corners.
No pressure in the air.
No sense that the room was listening.
That mattered.
Dave locked the basement door behind them.
Not because a lock could stop what they had met at Loomis, but because disciplined investigators secured what could be secured before speaking about what could not.
Pastor Elias set the Bible on the table.
“First we clear the night.”
No one argued.
They all knew the rule.
You did not leave a troubled house and carry its atmosphere into sleep or analysis. You did not let adrenaline interpret evidence for you.
Phones were silenced.
The Bible opened.
Pastor Elias read quietly from the Psalms.
Then he prayed.
For the family on Loomis Street.
For clear memory.
For no attachment, no confusion, and no fear to follow anyone home.
When he finished, the room remained silent.
“You go home clean tonight,” he said.
No one stayed.
No one reviewed the evidence.
They left.
Morning brought winter back.
Thin ice filmed the church parking lot where the thaw had frozen overnight.
They met again in the basement.
Cid was not there.
Pastor Elias had asked him to stay away for the first review.
Four men sat at the table.
Pastor Elias.
Daniel.
Mike.
Father Moreno.
Father Moreno had arrived early.
Silver hair.
Thin face.
Calm eyes that rarely showed surprise.
The case file lay on the table.
Photographs.
Interview reports.
Environmental notes.
And the audio recorder.
Behind them the basement looked as it always had.
A wall clock hung above the filing cabinets.
A small plastic clock sat near the coffee maker.
Beside the office phone rested a brass desk clock.
Three clocks.
Father Moreno rested his hands on the table.
“Start with the ordinary.”
“Always,” Elias said.
Daniel slid the photographs across.
Exterior shots.
The front room.
Mattresses pushed together.
The stairwell.
The upstairs hall.
Father Moreno studied each photograph.
“No one sleeping alone.”
“No.”
“Eating in the same room.”
“Yes.”
“The disturbance is already reorganizing the household.”
Mike connected the recorder.
“Start with the stairwell unit,” Father Moreno said.
Mike pressed play.
Room tone filled the speaker.
Then the knocks.
Knock.
Knock.
Knock.
Clean.
Measured.
The recording continued.
Footsteps in the hall.
Slow.
Even.
Then the soft closing of a door.
Then music slipped through the speaker.
Low.
Thin.
“In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida.”
Daniel turned toward Mike.
Mike hadn’t moved.
Then another layer forced itself into the recording.
Fast scratching.
Animal sounds.
Too many.
The speaker cracked with static—
and died.
Mike leaned toward the machine.
At his ear, close enough to feel, a voice whispered:
“Mike.”
He spun hard enough to jar the chair.
No one stood near him.
Daniel looked up.
“What?”
Mike stared into the empty air.
Father Moreno pointed to the recorder.
“Play it again.”
Mike rewound the tape.
Pressed play.
Room tone.
The three knocks.
The footsteps.
The door closing.
Nothing else.
Then the temperature in the basement fell.
Hard.
Immediate.
Breath appeared in the air.
The fluorescent lights dimmed.
Then the wall clock stopped.
Then the plastic clock near the coffee maker.
Then the brass desk clock beside the phone.
Three clocks.
Three small mechanical deaths.
Silence thickened in the room.
Father Moreno stood.
“That is enough.”
The cold did not lift.
The clocks remained frozen.
Daniel spoke quietly.
“That wasn’t on the recorder last night.”
“No,” Father Moreno said.
Everyone in the room understood the same thing.
Whatever had altered the recording had not done it at Loomis Street.
It had waited.
And when it answered—
it answered here.
The decision was made in that silence.
Father Moreno looked once more at the stopped clocks.
Then at Pastor Elias.
“We do not need another visit to know what this is becoming.”
He gave the order plainly.
“We prepare the house.”
